rbl Brand Agency

What we can all learn from the changes facing university branding

Universities are facing a brand crisis. But look closely, and you’ll see a challenge confronting almost every major organisation.

Higher education is at a crossroads. Financial pressures are mounting, competition is intensifying, audiences are questioning established measures of value, and institutions are struggling to stand apart.

Sound familiar?

From professional services to financial institutions, technology businesses to membership organisations, the same forces are reshaping markets. And the response is often remarkably similar: when uncertainty increases, organisations retreat towards what feels safe.

The problem?

Safety is making everyone look the same. When everyone is different, nobody is.

At rbl, we’ve worked with universities for over a decade. Our latest research, conducted with Tracksuit, reveals something uncomfortable.

Across 18 university brands, only 10–30% of students associated institutions with appealing qualities. Different universities, different histories, different strengths. Yet remarkably similar perceptions.

The sector has become trapped in a language of world-class teaching, employability, transformation and excellence.

All credible claims. Few genuinely distinctive.

And this isn’t unique to universities. Every sector has its own version of ‘world-class’. The promises that once communicated competitive advantage gradually become the minimum expectations of the category.

When everyone claims the same strengths, audiences fall back on what they can easily compare: price, location, scale, rankings or specifications.

That’s a dangerous place for any brand to find itself. Your reputation might not mean what you think it means.

Perhaps the most revealing finding concerns prestige.

Our research with more than 750 high-performing prospective students found that practical considerations such as course content, entry requirements and location outweighed traditional signals of heritage and exclusivity. The things institutions have spent decades celebrating aren’t necessarily the things audiences value most.

There’s a lesson here for every established organisation.

Heritage can become baggage. Expertise can become an expectation. Scale can suggest bureaucracy rather than strength. None of these assets has lost its value. But their meaning is changing.

The question isn’t simply what makes your organisation impressive. It’s what makes you relevant to the people whose choices will determine your future.

Trust is becoming a competitive advantage.

Tracksuit’s research found that people associating a university with trust were 2.4 times more likely to move from awareness to consideration.

That’s a significant finding. It suggests the commercial opportunity isn’t necessarily to become better known, but to make being known more valuable.

Yet trust cannot be manufactured through communications alone. It comes from the relationship between what an organisation promises and what people actually experience.

For universities, that means teaching, support, belonging and outcomes. For other organisations, it might mean service, innovation, employee behaviour or customer experience.

The principle is identical.

A brand promise without operational proof is simply an ambition.

Brand needs a bigger job. This is where I believe the greatest opportunity lies.

Too often, brand is treated as the final expression of organisational strategy. Something to communicate once the important decisions have been made.

But what if brand helped make those decisions?

What if it influenced where organisations invest, how teams behave, which partnerships they pursue and what experiences they create?

Our research identifies three areas where universities can turn brand ambition into genuine advantage: environment, culture and experience. These are equally powerful levers for any complex business.

Because the strongest brands don’t simply describe what makes an organisation different. They help people across that organisation create that difference, consistently.

The question every leadership team should ask.

The challenges facing universities aren’t exceptional. They’re a particularly visible example of a much bigger shift.

Audiences are changing. Traditional advantages are weakening. And organisations that compete through familiar promises risk becoming increasingly interchangeable.

So perhaps it’s time to stop asking whether your brand accurately reflects your organisation. And start asking something more ambitious.

Is your brand helping your organisation become what it needs to be next?

Because the future won’t belong to those who communicate difference most convincingly.

It will belong to those who create it.

 

Read the full report here.